About Secret History

Commentary on Latin America.
Mostly about Mexico - but not always.
Designed to encourage readers to learn about
the apparently "secret history" of 500 million people
spread across two continents
- but not always.
You can always count on a little snark.

Showing posts with label violence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label violence. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Mary and Her Disgusting Blogging

Mary Scriver over at the Prairie Mary blog has a great essay this week about the complexity of race and indigenous identity in relation to ideas of "disgust" and "disgusting." Well connected to the Piegan of the Rocky Mountain front of Montana in towns like Heart Butte and Browning, Mary is a great observer of how Indians are portrayed and "dealt with" by the local white population. You can't help but read Mary's thoughts and think of the treatment of the Tarahumara in Chihuahua or the poor indigenous beggars in Mexico's cities. Says Mary of the ways people use to talk about "dirty Indians":
Today’s civilized people do not use such words. They come from hierarchal [sic] assumptions based on the European empires, particularly the English, who used stigma to control their subject countries. But contemporary Native American people must still emphasize their professional, educated, and meticulously conventional qualities in order to get respect. Even the school children respond to the advertising-driven obsession with cleanliness, not smelling, “proper” clothes and other appearance markers that are meant to prevent disgust.
I like Mary's blog because it does a great job of reminding me of the similarities between Latin America and the United States. And while the ideas are there, you get a bit of Foucault in Mary's post without having to put up with his language - a real bonus! At any rate, the following passage certainly reminds me of the situation for the indigenous in Guerrero, Oaxaca, and Chiapas:
In the practical world, a stigmatized person is thought to deserve punishment for the original sin of being dark-skinned or poor. A couple of decades ago an enrolled Blackfeet drunk (oh, disgusting!) pestered around a bar until the bar owner simply shot him dead. The tribal people started out being indignant but pretty soon they drifted back to the bar, saying that the drunk asked for it with his disgusting behavior. Times have changed. Not long ago three brothers who liked violence picked out what they thought was a likely victim in the parking lot of a bar at quitting time: a drunk Indian ranch hand. But in the middle of their melee, another Indian -- a tribal council member and his wife -- tried to stop it, so the fun-lovers turned their fists and boots on them. The interveners were not powerless. They knew how to use the law. The brothers are serving jail time. But even the tribal council member was accused of the disgusting practice of hanging around in a bar until closing time.
I blogged about this incident of Mexican brothers beating Montana Indians and using the phrase "dirty Indian" while doing it in 2009.

Sunday, June 13, 2010

News From Ciudad Juarez

This just in from the Conference of Latin American Historians mailing list:

ARMED MEN VIOLATE THE SECRECY OF THE ONLY SAFE REFUGE FOR WOMEN IN SITUATIONS OF EXTREME VIOLENCE IN CIUDAD JUAREZ, CHIHUAHUA

The following Human rights groups: Centro de Derechos Humanos de las Mujeres, Mesa de Mujeres de Ciudad Juárez y SIN VIOLENCIA A.C;

DENOUNCE the following:

On 9 June, 14 heavily armed men broke into a secret safe house in Ciudad Juárez, the only one of its kind in the state of Chihuahua for women under situations of extreme violence. The refuge, Sin Violencia, A.C., was founded by the late Esther Chávez Cano. The leader of the squad was a public servant from the judiciary branch, named Román García, who refused to identify himself and only presented the women with a legal document signed by First Judge in Family Matters for the Bravos Judicial District, Guadalupe Manuel de Santiago Aguayo, who authorized the use of public force to break and enter the premises, as part of a procedure concerning family matters, "consistent with the immediate turnover of the minor Lesly Itzel Muñoz González."

The legal order did not state an address to carry out said judicial procedure, nor was it directed at Sin Violencia, a legally-registered Civil Association. Given the anomaly of the circumstances, the staff opposed the violent entry of the armed men into the refuge, and demanded that the judiciary officer present them with a search warrant, which he did not have.

The all-female staff explained that this was the only high-security REFUGE of its kind in Chihuahua and that some of the victims were wives or romantic partners of police officers, sicarios, or criminals linked to organized crime, so that for obvious security reasons they could not grant the men access to the premises. They explained that protocol banned entry to all men (not to mentioned armed men).

The women of Sin Violencia were threatened with 2-3 years of prison, and one of the armed men said, textually, "I urge you to cooperate, or I will be forced to act," at which point he gestured with his weapon. They then asked the executive coordinator to hand over her identification. One of the officers took her ID and said that he now had more information about the person refusing them entry, and said, "You're going to regret this, you'll be in trouble, it's better if you cooperate or we will break the locks and knock the doors down." Faced with the perceived threat of losing their lives in the hands of armed men who seemed willing to do anything; fearing the loss of their liberty and the further trauma that could be caused to the victims of violence who were inside, under their responsibility, and; threatened as they were by a group of armed men in a city of total impunity that is Ciudad Juárez currently, they felt forced to allow the armed men entry.

Once inside, the men acted violently, overturning furniture and looking under the beds of the victims, who went into a state of collective psychosis with their young children -- having considered the refuge to be a safe haven up until that moment.

The men did not find the minor in question, as the staff of Sin Violencia had forewarned the judicial officer in charge.

WE DEMAND:

The immediate dismissal from office of the judicial public servant and the police officers who participated in this action, as well as the required security to allow for the continuity of our human rights work.

Send your letters to:
Lic. Rodolfo Acosta Muñoz
Magistrado Presidente del Supremo Tribunal de Justicia
Del Estado de Chihuahua
Tel ( 52 614 ) 1 800 700

Lic. José Reyes Baeza
Gobernador Constitucional del Estado de Chihuahua
Palacio de Gobierno
Calle Aldama # 901 Col Centro C.P. 31000
Tel ( 52 614) 4 29 33 00 ext 11123

Send a copy to: Centro de Derechos Humanos de las Mujeres correo electrónico: acción@cedehm.org.mx

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Mexican Drug Commandos in Florida and Illinois

Narco-terrorist-illegal-immigrants penetrated US Territory over the last three weeks, killing two spring break students in drunken balcony falls and running over another out for a jog. Reports are still coming in about a Chicago teen on break struck and killed by 86 yr-old John Hillyard in Southern Illinois this week. Hillyard illegally arrived in this country from Oaxaca two years ago carrying forty pounds of marijuana and three kilos of powdered pseudoephedrine pills - all of which would have been consumed by OTHER illegal immigrants in the nation. If only all those spring breakers were armed.

I'm not sure that Iturbide or Morelos had in mind creating Mexico for the purpose of helping US Americans feel better about their own national problems, but that seems to be Mexico's most enduring hemispheric role in the minds of some US Americans. At any rate, the killing of an Arizona rancher seems to be the latest cause celebre of the anti-Mexican crowd, and the rhetoric surrounding it seems to be going nowhere pretty. Somehow I don't think the chant we'll hear at Arizona anti-immigration rallies will be something like "We'll kill our own, Mex go home."

Monday, March 22, 2010

Reading Mexico: Area Specialists Needed

Dallas Morning News carried an interesting analysis of the narcotics violence in Mexico by Andrew Steele of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for scholars. I would love to see an extended conversation with Steele and see him as a talking head more than some half-educated journalist. I think his observations are level-headed, and while I don't feel like I have to agree with everything he said, it at least has some logic behind it and avoids blanket buzz words like "apocalyptic" and "nightmare." Steele is a good example of the kind of commentary we should see the press going to instead of Wall Street Journal reporters or former Iraq correspondents plopped down in the Zona Rosa. Kudos to the Dallas Morning News and Alfredo Corchado for presenting a conversation that was worth reading. And double Kudos for Steele in acknowledging the corruption, criminal partners, and demand in the United States that make high-violence narco-crime in Mexico possible.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Human Rights and Security (Part 2)

Part two in a multi-part series of petitions and letters to Felipe Calderon asking for new approaches to the security issues in Juarez and Mexico.
__________

Cd. Juárez, Chih. a 11 de Febrero de 2010

Lic. Felipe Calderón Hinojosa
Presidente Constitucional de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos
Distinguidas autoridades
Presentes

1. Falló el Operativo.
Hablamos desde el dolor de nuestra ciudad, desde el dolor de las víctimas, de sus madres y sus familiares, de los más de 7,000 niños huérfanos, de todos los que se han visto obligados a irse de su ciudad, o a pagar extorsión. Del dolor de todos los juarenses. El número de homicidios dolosos pasó de entre 200 y 300 a más de 1,600 en 2008 y a más de 2,.650 en 2009. La cantidad de secuestros denunciados aumentó más de 300% durante 2009. La mayoría del comercio ha sido y es extorsionado. Por todo lo anterior afirmamos, como la inmensa mayoría de los juarenses, que en la forma como ha sido planteado actualmente el Operativo no tiene posibilidades de éxito.

2. Aunque el problema es complejo, causa central se encuentra en la corrupción de las policías municipal, estatal, federal y del ejército. (Nadie resiste 9,000 efectivos federales si no cuenta también con un gran número de policías y militares)

3. No planteamos la salida de las fuerzas armadas, pero sí la necesidad de un pacto político entre los diferentes niveles de Gobierno y fuerzas políticas, que permita una acción efectiva, sin importar los intereses que se afecten. El Estado en conjunto, necesita mandar el mensaje de respeto a la legalidad, repudiando la muerte y la destrucción. Señor Presidente, en la corrupción participan grandes empresarios, políticos y funcionarios de gobierno.

4. En cualquier esquema, necesitamos policía de investigación. Cada muerte de un policía de investigación es un golpe al corazón del Estado de Derecho. Exigimos la presencia de Ministerio Público Federal, en cantidad suficiente (al menos 200 agentes), profesionales, capacitados y cuidados con la protección del Estado. A esos sí que los cuiden los militares. Lo mismo
pedimos al nivel estatal, cuya Procuraduría se encuentra actualmente colapsada.

5. Esquemas de Inteligencia con presupuesto, y con todo el cuidado, la tecnología más moderna y el profesionalismo de los mejores sistemas disponibles en el mundo.

6. Mando Civil Único para el operativo, consensuado entre los tres niveles de Gobierno y la sociedad, que conjunte las fuerzas federales, estatales y municipales en un solo esquema de coordinación; y con un enlace civil claro de cara a la sociedad.

7. Acción efectiva contra los dirigentes y el lavado de dinero, y de ninguna manera sólo contra las pandillas. Operativo anti-extorsión y grupo antisecuestros profesional y de élite y apoyado en esta inteligencia y policía de investigación.

8. Acción policíaca y del Ejército, y leyes en consonancia con ello, con respeto irrestricto a las garantías individuales y los derechos humanos.

9. Necesitamos una auténtica política de Estado en materia social y de reactivación económica, y generación de empleo, porque con los niveles de desempleo y hambre actuales, no hay política de seguridad que alcance.

10. Y finalmente, el establecimiento de una mesa de seguimiento permanente a las acciones de seguridad, mediante el establecimiento de un Consejo Ciudadano con la presencia de los tres niveles de gobierno y la sociedad civil. Una lista con propuestas operativas concretas ha sido entregada al Señor Secretario de Gobernación.

Lic. Felipe Calderón Hinojosa, Presidente Constitucional de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos. Bienvenido a Ciudad Juárez, ésta su casa. A esta ciudad que ha sido siempre conocida por su hospitalidad y que hoy se encuentra devastada. Los juarenses hablamos desde nuestro dolor, desde el corazón. Estamos convencidos, quizá como Usted, que la viabilidad no de su Gobierno sino del Estado Mexicano está en juego en Ciudad Juárez. Su responsabilidad es grande.

Muchas gracias.

Mesa de Seguridad Pública

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Human Rights and Security (Part 1)

An academic list serve (listserv?) I belong to has been distributing letters regarding human rights by several working groups on security and human rights in Mexico. With their permission, I will spend the next few days posting their letters and petitions to Felipe Calderon.

I don't think it is appropriate to add my commentary. Perhaps some thoughts when the series finishes. Also, I understand the frequency of these sorts of petitions and letters in both the US and Latin America, but I have a soft spot in my academic heart for them, not so much for what they get done but what they tell us about the desires of those that write them.
---------

CIUDADANO FELIPE CALDERÓN HINOJOSA

EXIGIMOS EL RESTABLECIMIENTO DEL ESTADO DE DERECHO EN CIUDAD JUÁREZ, CHIHUAHUA.

NINGÚN PACTO Y NINGUNA INTERVENCIÓN PÚBLICA PUEDE PARTIR DE LA VIOLACIÓN SISTEMÁTICA DE LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS.

NO PODEMOS RECONSTRUIR JUÁREZ SI SE SIGUEN VULNERANDO LOS DERECHOS DE LA POBLACIÓN.

NO VAMOS A LEGITIMAR NINGUNA INTERVENCIÓN QUE NO TENGA COMO BASE ESTE PRINCIPIO.

CIUDAD JUÁREZ ESTÁ VIVIENDO UNA CATÁSTROFE. LA VIOLENCIA QUE VIVIMOS HA REBASADO TODOS LOS LÍMITES.

HEMOS PADECIDO IMPUNIDAD, VIOLACIÓN A LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS, TOLERANCIA, INDOLENCIA, PERMISIVIDAD, CORRUPCIÓN Y LA INCORRECTA INTERVENCIÓN POR PARTE DE LAS POLÍTICAS IMPLEMENTADAS DESDE EL CENTRO DEL PAÍS.

LA VIOLENCIA INSTITUCIONAL Y LA FALTA DE VOLUNTAD POLÍTICA PARA PROCURAR Y ADMINISTRAR LA JUSTICIA, QUE ES OBLIGACIÓN PRIMORDIAL DE LOS GOBERNANTES EN UN PAÍS QUE SE DICE DEMOCRÁTICO. LO ANTERIOR, AUNADO CON FACTORES DE TIPO ESTRUCTURAL SOCIAL Y ECONÓMICO ACUMULADOS DURANTE DÉCADAS POR EL ABANDONO DE ESTA CIUDAD Y, ENCIMA DE TODO, AHORA PADECEMOS LOS EFECTOS DE UNA GUERRA QUE NO PEDIMOS.

Las y los juarenses no podemos ser botín político-electoral, después del abandono en que el Estado ha tenido a Ciudad Juárez.
En este contexto, se propone lo siguiente:

Que salga el Ejército.
Se cuenta con más de 1000 casos documentados de desaparición forzada, tortura, ejecuciones extrajudiciales y robos, entre otros, cometidos por elementos del Ejército o fuerzas federales.

No se puede reestablecer el Estado de Derecho sin la absoluta sujeción de todos los poderes a la norma jurídica suprema que es la Constitución Política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos.

Se atienda de manera urgente, los casos de desaparición forzada por parte de las fuerzas federales, de las siguientes personas:
oCarlos Guzmán Zúñiga
oJosé Luís Guzmán Zúñiga
oJosé Ángel Alvarado Herrera
oNitza Paola Alvarado Espinoza
oRocío Irene Alvarado Reyes
oTomás Argijo González

Se atienda de manera urgente, los casos de ejecución extrajudicial por parte de las fuerzas federales, de las siguientes personas:
oSaúl Becerra Reyes
oDante Francisco Cruz

Tenemos cientos de niñas y niños huérfanos; mujeres solas; familias destruidas por la violencia. Proponemos la creación de una Oficina de Atención a victimas, que cuente con modelos específicos que parta de las necesidades de estas familias de acuerdo con los estándares internacionales y que retome las experiencias locales al respecto.

Desde la perspectiva de los derechos humanos, urge una reestructuración de todos los programas y planes de gobierno, no sólo en seguridad, sino también en prevención del delito y atención a grupos en situación de vulnerabilidad. Se necesita que las personas que estén al frente de la elaboración e implementación de estos programas, tengan la experiencia, capacidad y conocimiento de la problemática de Ciudad Juárez.

En Ciudad Juárez no hay acceso a la justicia, el sistema de procuración de justicia favorece que los criminales gocen de total impunidad. Existe rezago en la procuración de justicia y no se realiza una adecuada investigación de casos. Proponemos se asignen ministerios públicos suficientes a la ciudad, en el ámbito estatal y federal.

Con respecto al perfil de las autoridades que no son garantes de derechos humanos, exigimos se finquen responsabilidades penales y/o administrativas.

Se exige la creación de la Fiscalía Especializada para la Atención y Búsqueda de Mujeres y Niñas Desparecidas.

Se atienda de manera urgente, los siguientes casos de desaparición de mujeres:
oAdriana Sarmiento
oHilda Rivas Campos
oBrenda Ivonne Ponce Sáenz
oLidia Ramos Mancha
oBrenda Lizeth Vera Castro
oBrenda Berenice Castillo García
oMaria Guadalupe Pérez Montes
oMónica Jeannette Alanis Esparza, entre otros.

Se inste a la Comisión Nacional de los Derechos Humanos, para que, de manera permanente, designe para el Noroeste del Estado, personal adscrito a la segunda visitaduría, a efecto de crear mecanismos para la protección, promoción y defensa de los derechos humanos.

Exigimos que a las denuncias contra militares se les de seguimiento en las instancias civiles. Que haya transparencia en la investigación y que los afectados tengan conocimiento del estado en que se encuentran sus casos. Asimismo, que el Gobierno Federal asuma la responsabilidad civil por todos los daños ocasionados por las fuerzas federales, derivados de la implementación del Operativo Conjunto Chihuahua.

Exigimos que las autoridades de los tres órdenes de gobierno dejen de estigmatizar a las víctimas. Por lo tanto, exigimos una disculpa pública del Ciudadano Felipe Calderón a los familiares de las personas asesinadas en la colonia Villas de Salvarcar.

Exigimos un pronunciamiento inmediato y el compromiso público por parte del Ciudadano Felipe Calderón condenando los siguientes puntos:
oLa violencia contra las mujeres, expresadas en su máximo extremo en las desapariciones de mujeres y feminicidios.
oLa Tortura como medio sistemático de investigación.
oLa Desaparición Forzada por parte de Fuerzas Federales.
oY la falta de reconocimiento y protección a las y los Defensores de Derechos Humanos.

Sabemos que nuestra ciudad nunca volverá a ser la misma. Esta terrible experiencia de violencia que padecemos, constituye, según el Derecho Internacional de los Derechos Humanos, un delito de lesa humanidad. Exigimos medidas de no repetición.
CREACIÓN DE UN CONSEJO MIXTO DE LA SOCIEDAD Y EL GOBIERNO PARA ORIENTAR TODA LA INVERSIÓN Y EL GASTO SOCIAL, CON MECANISMOS DE TRANSPARENCIA.

EXIGIMOS RESTAURACIÓN Y NO LIMITACIÓN DE LAS GARANTÍAS INDIVIDUALES.
NADA EN JUÁREZ SIN LOS JUARENSES.

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Religious Violence Continues in Chiapas: The Other Rights

Demonstrators in San Cristobal de las Casas entered their seventh day of protest for expulsions and violence done to them by local Catholics in Chiapas since mid January and earlier. Some families have been expelled from communities while others have been detained for failure to participate in Catholic community festivals.

Such violence is not new - we've seen Catholic on Protestant expulsions for twenty years now as well as pro-government Protestant on Catholic violence since the Zapatista revolution started. I once read in well regarded book by an even better regarded author of Mexican history that the local and the sacred had been replaced by the national and the liberal. Horse hockey. Evengelicals and Protestants in Chiapas, Luz del Mundo in Guadalajara, Nueva Jerusalen in Michoacan ... all of these show that the intersection of the sacred and the citizen are alive and well in Mexico and not relegated to a distant mid-nineteenth century past.

At any rate, while Mexico City frets about the rights of gays to marry, fundamental right of association and property are violated every day in the mas alla for religious reasons without much attention from DF. Most certainly the local and the sacred have not been relegated to the dustbin of Mexican history.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Narco-Menonitas (Or So Says the PAN)

Rosa Maria Baray, a PANista state congress person from Chihuahua announced that the violence that is affecting the Mennonites in Chihuahua is something of their own doing. Says Baray:
"Así como en otros tiempos los menonitas se involucraron en delitos del fueron común, ahora también están tomando parte en actividades propias del narcotráfico." Read more here.
What she says, of course, has a some veracity. In the 1990s Mennonites were the largest transporters of marijuana into Canada, and the CBC has focused on the narcotics and violence present in the Anabaptists community in Canada and in Mexico (though melodramatically calling it the Mennonite Mafia). Indeed, Mennonites have certainly been involved in the black market economy of guns and drugs in not only growing and distribution, but also in using their mechanical skills to build automobile compartments for the transportation of contraband. On a personal note, in a visit to Chihuahua in 2007 with students our van driver suggested we not allow students to wander into the apple orchards surrounding our motel in Cuauhtemoc, Chihuahua as we might find people or items harmful to our "seguridad."

On the other hand... .
This sort of focus on the religion of the Mennonites allows everybody to get a little bit of exotic titilation (oooh...german speaking drug runners - isn't that for those dark Mexicans) while also satisfying the anti-religiuos bug (those pacifist hypocrites). It makes for good press in the same way a Protestant pastor that frequents male prostitutes gets attention: We like to see the sanctimonious cut down to size. However, would any activist of immigration approve of painting all Mexican Americans as illegal aliens who come to the U.S. with bales of Acapulco Gold strapped to their backs and leprosy in their blood? Painting the Mennonites with this broad-brush is inaccurate at best, and unfair to boot.

Again, while in Chihuahua in 2007 I had the chance to talk to the Mennonites about the detox center they've started in the campos to help the young people that have become involved with narcotics and alcohol. They are openly addressing a problem within society and are taking steps to correct the problems. Tobasco Hoy reports that Menonites have even created their own Guardia Civil (minus the guns) to patrol the campos and discourage not only outsiders but also members of the community from participating in crime. This is a long way from when Lazaro Cardenas authorized Mexican soldiers to apprehend and execute in the field criminals that harrassed Durango's Mennonites.

Anyway, the point being that Baray's comments allow Chihuahua to continue to try to marginalize a community that is one of the great legitimate economic engines of the state's economy based mostly on racial distrust and economic jealousy. If some Mennonites participate in narcotics, that doesn't make them less worthy of protection. Such logic applied to all Mexicans would eliminate whole cities and neighborhoods in Chihuahua - including many of the pueblos represented by Ms. Baray.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Anarchic Strife? What the heck?

This from the World Affairs Blog Network:

The gaping hole in President Calderón’s push to reform Mexico is local governance. Absent effective local police and bureaucracy problems like vigilantism emerge. With the drug gangs yet to be defeated and America pressing for results, Calderón is unlikely to divert his attention in the short-term. Anarchic strife in Mexico’s villages is sure to continue. At some point the Mexican reformer will have to reaffix his gaze.
Holy cow. I'm seriously reconsidering my link to their site.

Three things that burn my shorts on this one.

1) Calderon is a reformer? Glad World Affairs Blog is doing comedy these days.
2) "reaffix his gaze" Yes, by simply adjusting his glasses, Felipe can accomplish all. Super Barrio? No, Super Calderon!
3) Anarchic strife? Vigilantes are - in some places - stepping in to police the streets and beat and embarrass some rowdy kids? Even a general shooting a robber in his home - these hardly sound like the rumblings of the foundation of collapsing society (ala Guatemala). This week in our small town TWO sets of hunters went out with only one man coming back. Going out into the woods and shooting your hunting buddy six times seems like anarchic strife to me, not knocking the heads of some snotty kids.

Monday, October 5, 2009

Guns, Guns, Guns (sung to the Motley Crue tune)

This from the Houston Chronicle about guns from Texas:
Agents inspected gun dealer records and knocked on doors to ask people what happened to guns they purchased that ended up in Mexico. Among the cases that have yet to be resolved are those involving a small-town Texas policeman who bought a few military-style rifles, left them in his car and — on the same night — forgot to lock a door. He couldn't explain why he had not filed a police report or why he visited Mexico the next day.
Sigh. And I have students that freak out about going to Mexico because they think all the cops are dirty... .

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Hate Crimes, Indigenous Style?

Prairie Mary, whom I used to read with far more frequency before the baby was born, has posted an interesting note about a bar fight just off the Blackfoot reservation in Cut Bank, MT. Sez Mary:
The narrative: Three brothers, not Indians but possibly with some Mexican blood, liked to fight and had been drinking all evening. At closing time, 2AM, they chose as their victim a hired hand, a Native American single guy who was mild-mannered and well-liked, but not very good at self-control or social smarts, esp. once he was drunk. They picked a fight with him and all three began to beat on him. When he went to the ground, they began to kick.

A Native American county commissioner came out with his wife, saw what was happening and decided to intervene. At first he just remonstrated, saying he was going to call the police. (He had a cell phone.) So the brothers began to beat him and took him down. His wife tried to help but she, too, was shoved and sent flying. By that time enough people were there that the brothers thought they should get scarce.

But the county commissioner, a handsome and resourceful man from a strong rez family chose to make an issue out of it. He tried to press charges, saying it was a “hate crime” because the men were shouting phrases like “dirty Indian.” The white county attorney refused, saying that it was NOT a hate crime, just a fight as usual.

Read the whole post.... (A great discussion of race and class.)
Indigenous folks in the United States and citizens of Mexico (and the empire before it) have had close ties for generations. Nevertheless, I don't think most Anglos think about those ties - at least not since we quit making Westerns - and perhaps many U.S. Americans of Mexican descent don't either. Last semester one girl gasped when I said that we were going to talk about the right of those of indigenous descent in the United States, but that we were not yet going to focus on people who self identified as being descended from one of the Latin American nations. She raised her hand and said that she had never thought of herself and U.S. Native Americans having anything in common.

Anywho, a couple things struck me about this post from the talented Prairie Mary:

1) The county decision not to call it a hate crime. In Latin America if you have a few mestizo guys whooping up on a guy shouting "Indio sucio," I don't think anybody would think twice about calling it a racially motivated crime. Of course in Guerrero or Oaxaca you might just call it the police.

2) The fall back position that this was just a standard bar fight for the area. You know, all those hot-blooded folks like fightin' anyway. (***Please note that last sentence was written dipped in irony and dripping with exasperation***)

The Great Falls Tribune had an article on the incident, but what I liked most about that post was the comment of one of the readers. To find an "impartial" jury they moved the trial to the extreme NW corner of the state - the Lilliest portion of the state bristling with militia members, drugged up vets, and white supremacists (at least it was 15 years ago). Violence in Latin America, indeed.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

"No pierdas el tino..."

There ... are ... no ... words.

Click the picture. See the site.

Monday, July 27, 2009

Violence in Mexico - Another Thursday in Paradise

Last Thursday in my tiny Texas town of 30,000 - hundreds of miles from the border and three hours from any major American City:

1) Man blows away his wife in front of the kids then shoots himself. Two deaths. Two orphans.

2) Three drive-by shootings in the same apartment complex within three hours.

3) Over a dozen arrests in a raid on an apartment complex just two blocks from a public school and 5 blocks from the university - an apparent entire narco-apartment complex.

Welcome to rural, red-state, heartland, US of A.

Monday, June 29, 2009

This week in Nacogdoches... Violence in Mexico

Aryan Nations thugs kidnapped a girl.

A vagrant tried to kidnap my neighbors three kids.

A football player was shot and killed outside a BBQ joint.

An armored car was robbed at a bank.

A 27 year old woman shot a 5-year old in a drive by shooting.

A 14-year old was stabbed in the gut by thugs.

A man was gunned down by a stranger as he pushed a disabled car across the street.

In the last couple months a man shot and killed his wife through the kitchen window and burglars shot and killed a college student in his apartment...and two traffic accidents of drunk drivers killed 6 or 7 children down the road in Lufkin. Once more, I am AMAZED at the way my students talk about Mexico as a place of violence when the police report for the town they live is worse than they probably even know.

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Ozumba...Or, More on Violence in Mexico

Recently I was looking at videos onYouTube for the town where I did some of my dissertation research. Ozumba is a great little town - religiously a bit of an odd duck, but as a community it is quite a place to visit (like any of the medium sized market towns in rural Mexico). Clearly most of the videos were a celebration of community civic/religious culture and probably as important to Ozumba "ex-pats" as to the town itself. That's when I found:



Ouch. Again, my concern on violence in Mexico has less to do with organized crime and more to do with the insidious form taken in the video (and the same concern I have for violence in the US or anywhere else): Violence of hate between two parties as entertainment for others. US snuff films, torture-porn, Mexican tabloids...this is the violence that concerns me more than the clash of two cartels. Even TV violence, that generates up to 40 acts of violence an hour doesn't disturb me as much as this personal expression of lust for blood. What distinguishes the psychopath from the rest of society is the inability to feel compassion or sentiment for other people as people. They see them only as objects that revolve around the personal sphere of the psychopath, deserving of care or attention only when they fit the needs of the psychopath. Understandably, the materialist US society generates more psychopaths than Mexico, but this video reminds me that the crumbling of community in Mexico and the link to personal violence is very real.

Monday, April 6, 2009

Mexican Violence Spills Over...


Mexican drug cartels put more notches in their belts in early 2009 as violence from the border spilled over to Binghamton, NY, Pittsburgh, PA, Pinelake, NC, Santa Clara, CA, and Geneva, AL. (I actually think I missed a couple.)

Conservatives have resolved to remedy the problem of violence in the United States by building a wall across private land in Texas and raiding the Home Depot parking lot in San Gabriel, California.

Guns don't kill people, a psychic link to violent Mexican culture kills people.
Having had to cancel a course that would travel to Mexico because parents have panicked about "violent" Mexicans, I was struck by the absurdity of two people being gunned down last week in our small town. The news has been dripping with mass killings and here in Texas local legislators are introducing a bill to allow university and college students (STUDENTS!!!) to carry weapons in the class room. Violent society? This is surreal ... an exploration of the absurd.

For conservatives ready to go after Mexico on "violence" in society, pick up your own "guiding set of principles" and read St. John 8:1-9.

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

A Lesson From Home for ... well, is that for D.C. or D.F.?

This is an interesting post from US News and World Report back in December of 2008. The discussion is of Aurora, Illinois.

The mid-1990s was the height of gang violence, when police logged hundreds of shootings and around two dozen murders per year. Funeral parlors refused to hold services for slain teens, fearing, with good reason, that reprisal gang attacks would come at the gravesides. The local cops, meanwhile, were moving from shooting to shooting so quickly they could hardly keep up, much less close cases. There were so many shell casings at some crime scenes, the old-timers joke, that police started kicking them into the sewers to avoid the crime lab paperwork. "It became so routine," says Police Chief Greg Thomas. "It was shooting after shooting after shooting with no way to break the cycle."


So, is Illinois a "failed state"? Not sure this is really the case. So, how exactly did the ATF deal with the problem in Illinois and reduce the violence.

Gunrunners. The strategy the ATF employed, in concert with local police and federal prosecutors, is one it is using increasingly. Federal agents spend their time on stakeouts, undercover busts, and working informants. They call on regional SWAT teams from the ATF to capture their most high-risk targets. The focus on major gunrunners has made it more difficult for gangs to regularly get their hands on dependable weaponry, experts say. As violence declines, local police and social workers can step in.

Monday, December 8, 2008

El Signo De La Muerte


The Houston Chronicle reported on Saturday that the reinstatement of the death penalty in Mexico is unlikely to get the 2/3 majority needed to reinstate the death penalty there. And while I felt a little more sympathy for Benito Juarez last week, the statement by the La Arquidiócesis Primada de México has gone a long way to get me back on the path. I consistently battle to get my students to see Mexico as a nation that has aspects of political and international leadership that the United States could learn from. But, as the Catholics are putting it, the death penalty is reinstated, we are looking at nothing more than “un instrumento más para la injusticia humana”.
On the other hand, I'd certainly like to see more done by the Catholic Church on the LOCAL level to deny known narcotraficantes the ability to partake in the sacraments as well as participate in the community festivals that help gain them local respect and honor. While some movement was made on that front in the 1990s, I'm not sure much has been done since the response to the killing of Posadas Ocampo.

And my apologies to the Cantinflas fans for the choice of title....

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

The OTHER Violence in Mexico

As the narco-violence in Mexico grows, my students are expressing extreme distress about our upcoming trip to Mexico City and Oaxaca. Aside from pointing out to them that 2 people an hour are murdered in the US, I pointed out a statistic that worries me a little more. Last year at this time the Calderon administration discussed a fairly disturbing number: 80% of women murderd in Mexico are killed by a family member, and 30% of women assaulted felt the attacker did it out of love. At the same time, Calderon mentioned that the traffic of humans - not just for migration - is the third most profitable crime in Mexico, with 80% of the victims being young girls and women.

I hate that my students watch the news and have a "Barbarous Mexico" moment, one that will probably stop them from going to Mexico and learning more about it in a way that could help them contribute to it as fellow citizens of the world. Well, a way beyond stopping their own possible recreational narcotics habits and funding the cartels...but I guess that is best left for another post.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

They Say You Want a Revolution

This week my students are discussing Daniel Cosio Villegas and the idea of the Mexican Revolution being alive or dead. Some have gotten bogged down with the question as early as 1911, but others are plugging right along in 2008. I am curious about the centennial celebrations, bicentennial celebrations, and the current war with the narcotraficantes that is dominating many of the headlines these days. Is the Calderon push a new Revolution to take Mexico back from organized crime, or is it the effort of a despot looking to stifle a black market economy that provides income for otherwise impoverished sectors? I know I am less convinced of the mafiosos and their altruistic intentions, but it is hard to travel in Chihuahua and not see their hands working to the benefit of local economies on the surface.

On a happier note, I was interested to see the official government site celebrating the Revolution has items on there from Catholic participants. Take a look. The home site can be found here. I'm sure the intro video will be deconstructed in class rooms accross academia using Ilene V. O'Malley and Thomas Benjamin.